25 Questions to Ask an SEO Agency Before You Hire

Published  11 min read
Table of Contents
  1. Questions About Experience and Results
  2. Questions About Strategy
  3. Questions About Guidelines and Transparency
  4. Questions About Reporting and Measurement
  5. Questions About the Team and Communication
  6. Questions About Pricing and Contracts
  7. Questions a Good SEO Agency Should Ask You
  8. How to Score the Answers
  9. Find SEO Agencies to Interview on Today SEO World
  10. FAQs
Business owner asking an SEO agency questions on a discovery call

Questions About Experience and Results

1. Can you show us case studies from businesses like ours?

Why ask: Past results for a similar business are the best guide to what an agency can do for you. Google’s own advice is to ask for “examples of your previous work” and “success stories.”

Good answer: Two or three case studies from your industry or business model, showing the starting point, the work done and the business results.

Red flag: Only logos and testimonials, or “our results are confidential” with nothing else to show.

2. What results did those clients get, and how long did they take?

Why ask: A case study without numbers or dates tells you little about what to expect.

Good answer: Specific changes in leads, sales or organic traffic, with the timeframe and what the agency did to get there.

Red flag: Only ranking screenshots, or results with no dates.

3. What’s your experience in our industry and our country or city?

Why ask: Google suggests asking both. Industry knowledge shortens the learning curve, and market experience matters for local and international SEO.

Good answer: Named clients or projects in your sector or market, and a clear understanding of how your customers search.

Red flag: “SEO is the same for every business.”

4. Can we speak to one or two current clients?

Why ask: References tell you how the agency behaves after the contract is signed.

Good answer: A yes, with contacts you can call or email. Ask them how long they’ve worked together, what changed and whether they’d hire the agency again.

Red flag: No references at all, or only clients from years ago.

5. How long have you been in business, and how long do clients usually stay?

Why ask: Google lists “How long have you been in business?” as a key question. How long clients stay shows whether they keep getting value.

Good answer: A clear answer to both, ideally with many clients staying well beyond their first contract term.

Red flag: Avoiding the client retention question.

Questions About Strategy

6. What would you focus on first for our website, and why?

Why ask: The answer shows whether the agency has actually looked at your site.

Good answer: Two or three specific priorities based on your site and goals, with the reasoning behind each.

Red flag: A standard package that would be the same for any business.

7. What results do you expect for us, and in what timeframe?

Why ask: It’s one of Google’s suggested questions, and the answer shows whether the agency sets honest expectations.

Good answer: A realistic range, with the assumptions behind it and what could speed results up or slow them down.

Red flag: Exact ranking positions, or big results “within weeks.”

8. How do you choose which keywords to target?

Why ask: Targeting the wrong keywords brings traffic that never turns into customers.

Good answer: Research based on search intent and your customers, prioritizing keywords that lead to enquiries or sales, not just high search volume.

Red flag: A list of popular keywords with no link to your business goals.

9. How do you handle technical SEO?

Why ask: Problems with crawling, indexing or site speed can hold back everything else.

Good answer: A technical audit at the start, a prioritized list of fixes and a clear process for who makes the changes on your site.

Red flag: An audit with no follow-up, or no technical work at all when your site clearly needs it. If your site is large or complex, compare technical SEO agencies.

10. How do you create and improve content?

Why ask: Content is often the biggest part of the work, and quality varies widely.

Good answer: A content plan tied to your keywords and customers, with clarity on who writes it, how your experts are involved and how it’s checked.

Red flag: Bulk articles written for search engines rather than readers, or unedited AI-generated content.

11. How do you get links to client websites?

Why ask: Link building done badly can break Google’s spam policies and hurt your site.

Good answer: Earning links through useful content, digital PR and genuine relationships.

Red flag: Buying links, private blog networks or “1,000 backlinks a month.” Google warns against SEOs that talk about “link popularity schemes.”

12. How are you approaching AI Overviews and AI search?

Why ask: More searches now show AI-generated answers, so you want an agency with a sensible plan for them.

Good answer: A plan built on SEO basics, such as clear, well-structured content and genuine brand mentions, plus a way to track where your brand appears in AI answers.

Red flag: “Secret AI hacks,” or an expensive separate AI package with no clear explanation. If AI visibility is a priority, compare GEO agencies.

Questions About Guidelines and Transparency

13. Do you follow Google Search Essentials?

Why ask: Google lists this question, and the answer tells you whether the agency’s methods are safe for your site.

Good answer: A clear yes, with examples of how its content and link work follow Google Search Essentials.

Red flag: Hesitation, or “everyone bends the rules a little.”

14. Can you guarantee rankings?

Why ask: It’s a test question. Google says: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.”

Good answer: No, with an explanation of what the agency can commit to instead, such as the work it will deliver and the metrics it will report.

Red flag: Any guarantee of rankings or page-one positions.

15. Will you share every change you make to our site?

Why ask: Google suggests asking whether an SEO will share all its changes and explain the reasoning behind its recommendations.

Good answer: Yes, with a change log and a short explanation for each recommendation.

Red flag: Changes made without telling you, or “that’s our proprietary method.”

Questions About Reporting and Measurement

16. How will you measure success?

Why ask: Agreeing on KPIs up front prevents arguments later.

Good answer: 3 to 5 KPIs tied to your goals, such as leads, sales or calls, supported by metrics like organic traffic and rankings.

Red flag: Rankings and traffic as the only measures.

17. How often will you report, and what will reports include?

Why ask: Reports are how you’ll know whether your money is working.

Good answer: Monthly reports in plain language covering results, work completed and next month’s priorities, plus a regular call.

Red flag: Automated reports with no commentary.

18. Which tools do you use, and will we see the data?

Why ask: You should be able to check the numbers yourself.

Good answer: Named tools, such as Google Search Console, Google Analytics 4 and a rank tracker, plus access to the data or a shared dashboard.

Red flag: Data you can only see as screenshots in their reports.

19. How will you track leads and sales from SEO?

Why ask: Traffic only matters if it turns into business.

Good answer: Conversion tracking in Google Analytics 4 for forms, calls or purchases, and reports on conversions from organic search.

Red flag: No plan to track conversions at all.

Questions About the Team and Communication

20. Who will actually work on our account?

Why ask: The people on the sales call are often not the people who do the work.

Good answer: Named team members, their roles and roughly how many hours a month they’ll spend on your account.

Red flag: Vague answers, or work passed to freelancers or partners without telling you.

21. How will we communicate, and how quickly do you respond?

Why ask: Google suggests asking how you can expect to communicate with an SEO.

Good answer: A named contact, a regular meeting schedule and a clear response time, such as one business day.

Red flag: Contact only through a general support inbox.

22. What do you need from our team?

Why ask: SEO often needs your developer’s time, approvals and expert input to move quickly.

Good answer: A clear list of what the agency needs from you and how much of your time it takes each month.

Red flag: “Nothing, we’ll handle everything,” which often means changes never get made.

Questions About Pricing and Contracts

23. What exactly does the monthly fee include, and what costs extra?

Why ask: Two agencies charging the same fee can deliver very different amounts of work.

Good answer: Written monthly deliverables, with upfront prices for extras such as content writing, links, tools and setup. Our guide on how much an SEO agency costs shows typical prices, so you can check whether a quote is fair.

Red flag: “Ongoing optimization” with no detail.

24. What’s the minimum contract term and notice period?

Why ask: A long lock-in leaves you stuck if the agency underperforms.

Good answer: A reasonable first term, such as 3 to 6 months, with a short notice period after that.

Red flag: A 12-month lock-in before you’ve seen any work.

25. What happens to our content, data and accounts if we part ways?

Why ask: You should keep everything you’ve paid for.

Good answer: You keep all content, reports and data, and the agency works in your Google Search Console, Google Analytics and Google Business Profile as a user, not the owner.

Red flag: The agency owns your accounts, or charges a fee to hand them over.

Questions a Good SEO Agency Should Ask You

Google’s advice is to “see if the SEO is interested in you and your business.” A good agency will ask about:

  • Your business goals, and which products or services matter most
  • Your customers and how they buy
  • Your profit margins, or what a new customer is worth
  • Past SEO work, penalties or website migrations
  • Who on your team can make changes to the website
  • Your budget and timeline

If an agency sends a proposal without asking about any of these, it’s selling a package, not a plan.

How to Score the Answers

Score each answer from 1 to 5 as you go, then compare the totals across agencies.

Answer quality Score
Specific, honest and backed by evidence 5
Credible but general 3
Vague, evasive or a red flag 1

A red flag on question 11, 13, 14 or 25 (links, guidelines, guarantees or account ownership) should rule an agency out, whatever its total. For a weighted comparison of full proposals, use the scorecard in our guide on choosing an SEO agency.

Find SEO Agencies to Interview on Today SEO World

Ready to start your calls? Browse SEO agencies by service, location, budget and team size, and shortlist three to five to interview. Once you’ve worked with one, write a review to help other businesses choose.

Run an SEO agency? Get your agency listed so businesses looking for an SEO partner can find you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to common questions about this topic.

What is the most important question to ask an SEO agency?

Ask, "What would you focus on first for our website, and why?" The answer shows whether the agency has looked at your site and can explain a specific plan. Close behind are questions about case studies, how success is measured and who owns your accounts.

How many questions should I ask an SEO agency?

You don't need all 25 on one call. Send the experience and pricing questions in writing beforehand, then use the call for strategy, reporting and team questions. Ask every agency the same questions so you can compare them fairly.

What questions will an SEO agency ask me?

A good agency will ask about your goals, your customers, what a new customer is worth, past SEO work, your website setup and your budget. If it asks nothing about your business, treat that as a warning sign.

Should I ask an SEO agency about AI search?

Yes. Ask how it will help your brand appear in Google's AI Overviews and in AI assistants such as ChatGPT. A good answer builds on SEO basics and includes a way to track AI visibility. Be wary of "secret" AI tactics.

What are the red flags when talking to an SEO agency?

The biggest red flags are guaranteed rankings, secret methods, buying links, no references, reports that show only rankings, long lock-in contracts and keeping your accounts in the agency's name.

Today SEO World Team

Written by

Today SEO World Team

Editorial Team

The Today SEO World Team is the editorial team behind Today SEO World, a directory for comparing SEO agencies, SEO tools and AI search services. We write practical guides on hiring agencies, SEO pricing, tool comparisons and AI search visibility, using official sources such as Google Search Central and vendors' own pricing pages. Payment never changes our ratings, reviews or editorial opinions, and sponsored content is always labelled.

  • Technical SEO
  • PPC
  • AI Search
  • Digital Marketing
List your agency or SEO tool for free.
Get found by businesses comparing SEO agencies, tools and AI search services.
  • Get discovered by buyers
  • Grow your brand and credibility
  • Show your services and rates
Free basic listing. Reviewed before it goes live.