Trust and transparency
How We List and Rate Agencies and Tools
Last updated:
People use Today SEO World to decide which agency to hire or which tool to buy, so they need to know how our lists work. This page explains who we list, what we check, what each label means, how our Recommended Score orders profiles and where ratings come from.
Who we list
- Agencies: SEO, PPC, content, link building, digital marketing and AI search agencies and consultants, listed in our agency directory.
- Tools: SEO, AI and marketing software, listed in our tool directory.
- AI search: agencies, tools and platform guides for AI search optimization.
How a profile gets on Today SEO World
- Our team adds it from public information, such as the company’s own website.
- The company submits it through Get Listed. The basic listing is free.
- The company claims it. If we already created the profile, the company can claim it and keep it up to date.
What we check before a profile goes live
- A person checks it: every new listing, claim and change is checked by someone on our team, usually within 2 working days. Nothing goes live automatically.
- Email confirmation: whoever sends a listing or claim must confirm their email address first.
- Proof for claims: we look at whether the claimer’s email is at the company’s own domain, and we may ask for more proof.
- Controlled fields: owners can update their description, logo, services, prices and other facts. Only our team can change the company name, website, category, reviews, ratings and badges.
- Complete profiles only: profiles with very little information are kept out of search engines until they are filled in.
What the labels mean
| Label | What it means | Paid? |
|---|---|---|
| TSW Verified | Our team checked the business documents: the business is registered and active, its website and profile details match, and the person managing the profile works there. The badge shows the date of our last check and lasts one year. See what we check | Usually. Some well-known tools carry it because our team verified them directly, without a paid plan |
| Sponsored | The company paid for a featured place | Yes |
| Verified client / Verified user (on a review) | Our team confirmed that the reviewer really worked with the agency or uses the tool, for example through their work email, LinkedIn, proof of work or a call | No. Reviewers never pay |
TSW Verified is not a recommendation or a quality score. It confirms that a business is real and that its details are correct.
How profiles are ordered on category pages
By default, category pages show profiles in this order:
- Sponsored profiles, which are paid placements
- TSW Verified profiles with a paid plan
- All other profiles, ranked by the Today SEO World Recommended Score
Rank numbers are shown only for profiles in the third group, because only that group is ranked purely on merit. You can always change the order (by reviews, newest, name or price) and filter by service, location, price and more.
The Recommended Score
The Recommended Score is our own score out of 100. It works like the ranking methods used by large B2B review websites: client reviews count most, followed by proven experience and how complete and checkable a profile is. We work it out automatically from the information on each profile and update it every day, so recent reviews keep their weight.
Agencies
| What we look at | Points | How it is scored |
|---|---|---|
| Client reviews on Today SEO World | 55 | Average rating (30), number of reviews (15), reviews from the last 12 months (5) and reviews from clients our team has confirmed (5) |
| Experience and proof of work | 15 | Years in business (10) and at least one case study with a result (5) |
| Profile quality | 20 | A full description, logo, location, services, industries, team size, hourly rate, minimum project size and a short summary |
| Market presence | 10 | A Google Business Profile linked to the profile (6) and a LinkedIn company page (4) |
Tools
| What we look at | Points | How it is scored |
|---|---|---|
| User reviews on Today SEO World | 55 | Average rating (30), number of reviews (15), reviews from the last 12 months (5) and reviews from users our team has confirmed (5) |
| Editorial assessment | 20 | Our editors’ overall assessment of the tool, scored out of 5 |
| Profile quality | 15 | A full description, logo, features, pricing, pros and cons, platforms, and free plan or trial details |
| Time on the market | 10 | Years since launch, the company behind the tool, and screenshots |
How reviews are scored
- Ratings are balanced: a profile with one 5-star review does not jump above a profile with twenty 4.8-star reviews. Every average is pulled slightly towards the middle until a profile has several reviews.
- Recent reviews count more: reviews older than one year count a little less, and reviews older than two years count less again.
- No reviews means no review points: a new profile can still rank on its experience and profile quality, but reviews make the biggest difference.
What never changes the score
- paying for a plan, a badge or an advertising placement (paid placements are shown above the ranked list instead, and are labeled)
- the Google rating shown on some agency profiles
- ratings from other review websites
- a company asking us to move it up
How ratings work
- Only our reviews count: star ratings on Today SEO World come only from reviews left on Today SEO World. We don’t copy ratings from other review websites.
- Every review is checked: reviews are confirmed by email and checked by a person before they go live. We refuse reviews from the company’s own email domain and allow one review per email address for each profile.
- No edits to opinions: we may fix spelling, but we never change a review’s meaning or its stars.
- Negative reviews stay: we never hide or remove a review because a company asks, or because it is negative. We remove reviews only when they break our review guidelines.
- Google is separate: some agency profiles also show their rating and up to 5 reviews from Google. These come straight from Google, are not checked by us and are never mixed into our rating.
What paying can and cannot change
Paying can:
- place a profile higher on category pages (Sponsored and paid TSW Verified)
- add features such as a clickable website link, social links, more case studies and a performance report
- add featured placements on the homepage and category pages
Paying never:
- changes a rating or a review
- removes or hides a review
- buys an editorial opinion, a place in our guides or a guest post
Our advertising and sponsorship disclosure explains how we make money.
Our articles and guides
Our editorial team writes and edits the articles on our SEO and AI search blog. Guest posts are free and edited by our team. We never accept payment for them. Paid content, such as a Fast-Track story or press release, is always labeled.
Found a mistake?
If a profile is out of date, a review breaks our guidelines or something looks wrong, use “Report a listing or review” on our contact page or email info@todayseoworld.com. We check every report, usually within 2 working days. You can also read more about Today SEO World.







